CNET: Clean Tech’s 5 Dirty Truths

July 20, 2007

Email this story Print this post Add your comments

Misperceptions have punctuated major industrial and IT changes and, according to a CNET article by Kirk Washington, they’ve taken hold today, as the clean-energy revolution gains currency in companies and communities

There are five dirty truths about clean technology people must keep in mind to make real progress. According to Washington:

#1 Clean tech is a puzzle that is not easily solved. There are a number of complex pieces that have to fit together, including cost, efficiency, emissions and, ultimately, sustainability. There is no magic energy elixir.

#2 Clean tech may reverse rampant globalization. As the cost of transporting certain forms of energy across vast distances becomes prohibitive, energy use will undoubtedly become more local and make better use of indigenous sources.

#3 We are probably offering false hope when we suggest that there is another generation of Edisons and Hewletts working in garages around America to fix our unprecedented environmental problems. In the end, this clean-technology revolution, unlike that for IT, may not be driven by venture capital-backed start-up companies.

#4 Collaboration, rather than competition, is going to win the day here. The large incumbent organizations in the old energy economy aren’t innovating fast or well enough. Their R&D budgets are shrinking, and the best and brightest engineers are no longer flocking to them.

#5 The only way that clean technology can fulfill its promise and potential is if venture start-ups and large established companies handle the upside and downside together. Venture capitalists routinely deal with risk, so that’s not a problem. The real issue is whether shareholders of publicly held enterprises will stomach the risk.

Email this story Print this post Add your comments

Advertisers

Enhance Sustainability. Improve Profitability.

Learn how at the SAP Sustainability Resource Center. >>

EFFECTIVELY MANAGE WATER COMPLIANCE

Understand how increased enforcement may affect your company. Find out more >>

EPA mandatory emissions reporting starts Jan 1st

CSA Standards can help your organization get ready for compliance. Find out how. >>

Join the Discussion

Reader Comments

Don’t know where to start.Let’s go by the #s. #1/2 yes sure but if you printed it on paper you’ve missed the point. Even electrons should go out back and die before repeating such truisms. #3 is just a flat out admission of pessimism and passive ignorance. Carpe millenium? #4 and 5 are as has ever been. Competition is by definition “striving together” Editor? Dirty is to truth as ye to verity amigo. Pardon my french.

R K | July 23rd, 2007