The Executive’s Daily Green Briefing

September 26, 2007

Energy Pulse: Wallets Drive Many Green Purchase Decisions

Companies that want to sell themselves as “green” and environmentally friendly must address product cost concerns as well as put their own money where their mouth is -? or else face rising skepticism with a cost-conscious and more discerning U.S. consumer, according to a national study that evaluates the consumer mindset on energy use and conservation, according to the third annual Shelton Group Energy Pulse study, to be released October 8.Companies that want to sell themselves as “green” and environmentally friendly must address product cost concerns as well as put their own money where their mouth is -? or else face rising skepticism with a cost-conscious and more discerning U.S. consumer, according to a national study that evaluates the consumer mindset on energy use and conservation, according to the third annual Shelton Group Energy Pulse study, to be released October 8.

Energy Pulse documents that purchase intention for every energy-efficient home product evaluated is down from the study’s 2006 results. For example, only 69 percent of consumers would choose one home over another based on energy-efficiency, down from 86 percent who said they would do so in 2006.

“Even with all the talk today about consumers seeking to save energy costs and help the environment, the shaky housing market and other recent economic uncertainties prove that wallets are still driving many Americans’green purchase decisions,” said Shelton Group CEO Suzanne Shelton. “As it stands, ‘?energy-efficient’ is consistently equated to ‘?more expensive’ in the minds of consumers for products across the board.”

“But saying ‘?save money’ when advertising an energy-efficient product isn’t necessarily good enough,” Shelton said. “Our research shows that consumers want proof. Messages also need to offer other subtle suggestions such as happiness, safety, peace of mind and security in order to resonate with what consumers desire.”

The finding is similar to a recent Marketing Profs article which said that green marketing must satisfy two objectives: Improved environmental quality and customer satisfaction. Misjudging either or overemphasizing the former at the expense of the latter is what can be called green marketing myopia - a corporate preoccupation with a products “greenness” rather than consumer needs.

In the Energy Pulse survey, when asked “Given an extra $10,000 in your construction budget for discretionary items, which of the following would you choose?” the top answers were:

• Granite counter tops (26 percent)
• Higher efficiency HVAC unit (24 percent)
• Upgraded or additional energy-efficient kitchen appliances (21 percent)
• Additional tile or hardwood (21 percent)
• Indoor air purification system (18 percent)
When asked, “If you were given $10,000 to make home renovations, which one or two things would you
do?” the top answers were:

• Replace carpet or add hardwood or tile (31 percent)
• Refinish kitchen or bathroom (29 percent)
• Repaint interior or exterior (27 percent)
• Replace windows (23 percent)

ADVERTISERS

Join the Discussion

Comments

We are a construction firm that roofs with an energystar rated system. We fully believe in the product that we sell to our customers. Our initial conversation with a prospecitve customer is typically about trying to explain that in the long run the product will save them money and help the environment by reducing landfill waste. I believe most people are visual and want to see the outcome immediatly, because their primary concern isn’t about the enviroment. Another way to put it is there is a lack of consumer education.
Your artical states that informing customers of the benefit/cost advantages of any energy efficiient product as a primary objective. In what ways can our organization become better at accomplishing this goal and what methods have been proven to be most reliable to do so?

Consumers Prefer ‘100% Natural’ Label Over ‘Organic’

Consumers Prefer ‘100% Natural’ Label Over ‘Organic’

In a study of consumer opinions of marketing claims, survey respondents identified most ...

click to view full size chart »

WWF Ranks US 7th Among G8 on Climate Scorecard
Growth of Global Carbon Emissions Cut in Half
Electricity, Heat, Transportation Cause 60% of Emissions

Today's News

Carbon Management IS Information Management

Carbon Management IS Information Management

For most organizations today, sophisticated carbon management is simply not possible. At best, ... continue »

The Hope Behind The Holes In The Climate Bill
Energy Costs Rising, Regulations Imminent - Are You Ready?
Energy - It Just Doesn’t Add Up
FTC on Greenwashing: Is That All There Is?
Shaklee Discusses its Green Strategies

Shaklee Discusses its Green Strategies

Shaklee Corp. was recognized recently ...

click to view video »

Sprint Tackles Data Center Improvements
Building a Bridge from Recycled Plastics
The Netherlands Ponders Floating City Architecture
Popular Topics

Marketing

Consumers Prefer ‘100% Natural’ Label Over ‘Organic’

Green Seal Adds First U.S. Standard for Personal Care Products

Show Sustainability Sales Success to Climb Corporate Ranks

Emissions

Cisco Wants to Transform Energy Demand and Use with Smart Buildings

Sony Europe Goes to 100% Renewable Energy

EPA Approves California Emissions Waiver

Hi-Tech

Sony Ericsson Joins Nokia, Samsung as ‘Greener’ Electronics Makers

Online Calculator Gauges IT Data Center Costs and Carbon Footprint

Microsoft Reduces Windows 7 Packaging

Efficiency

Black & Veatch HQ to Showcase Sustainability

Raytheon Meets Green Goals with IT Help

Yahoo! Dropping Carbon Offsets for Greener Data Centers

Manufacturing

Electronics Firms Face Off Against Mandated Recycling Programs

Leading Mobile Phone Makers Agree to Develop Universal Charger

Panasonic Cuts Manufacturing Emissions With Simulation Tech

Carbon Offsets/RECs

Sustainable Agriculture Requires Farm Modernization, Free Markets, Tech Adoption

Audi Promotes Clean Diesel via Facebook, Carbon Offsets

CBO: Cap-And-Trade to Cost $175 Per Household

CSR Reports

SAB Miller Targets 25% Reduction in Water Used in Brewing

Molson Coors Cuts CO2 Emissions by 12%

Successful Design in CSR Reporting, Part 2

Major Players

Fuel Cell Systems to Power 30% of Coca-Cola NY Facility

Australia Joins Carbon Reduction Label Scheme

CSX to Cut CO2 Emissions by 8%

See All Topics »