Carbon Tariffs Could Bring Manufacturers Back From Asia
Jeff Rubin, chief strategist and economist at CIBC World Markets, and a co-author of the report, thinks that once the U.S. institutes a cap on greenhouse gas emissions, a tolerance for countries that don’t, like China, will vanish.
Rubin predicts such a tariff, based on $45 a tonne of carbon dioxide and equivalent – about the current price on the carbon trading market in Europe – would collect $55-billion annually. It equates to a 17-per cent levy on all Chinese imports to the U.S. – almost six times greater than current import tariffs.
The advantage of cheap labor that has driven manufacturers to China would disappear, according to the report. (This brings up another issue which the report discusses, by shifting manufacturing production to China and then subsequently importing Chinese-made goods, the U.S. has exported what used to be its own GHG emissions to other countries.)
The industries that might leave, according to Rubin, would be the most energy intensive – plastics, chemicals and steel.
But carbon tariffs may be a difficult proposition. “Imposing tariffs on carbon, even if it could be done in a legal trade context, would be so complicated it would become a dangerous threat to trade stability,” Canada’s Financial Post, which says a carbon tariff is a recipe for global trade wars, reports.
To figure out the appropriate tax level would require a mind-blowingly elaborate carbon-measurement scheme, created on a global scale. It would have to be able to determine how much carbon emissions are embedded in the power drill that is nominally made in China, but is actually assembled from parts made in a dozen other countries. Some of those countries may or may not have carbon control programs in place.
Stay Up-to-Date On Environmental Management, Energy & Sustainability News with EL's Free Daily Newsletter
Energy Manager News
- Energy Storage in the Fast Lane
- Alberta Firm Aims for Energy Neutral Egg Laying Barn
- The Department of Energy Seeks to Improve the Better Buildings Challenge
- Behind the Meter: The Many Advantages of Energy Benchmarking
- Telecommunications Companies Upgrade Their Approaches to Energy
- Cutting Energy Use in Fire Stations
- Revolution Lighting Signs School Districts in NY, NJ
- Green Building Boom Is Pumping Billions into US Economy, Retrofits Are Fueling the Trend