The Executive’s Daily Green Briefing

August 26, 2008

Uptime CEO: Low PUE Numbers ‘Scientifically Meaningless’

rackdata.jpgThe Power Utilization Effectiveness metric can potentially be useful for determining the gross performance of data center electrical and mechanical systems. However, Kenneth Brill, executive director at Uptime Institute, which developed the concept, warns that PUE claims of 0.9, 1.2 or 1.6 in marketing materials are probably misleading. The typical numbers seen by the Uptime Institute?  2.0 or higher, Forbes reports.

PUE - which is being promoted by the Green Grid - measures the energy going into the data center and the energy delivered to IT equipment, with the difference being “power and cooling overhead.” A PUE of 2.0 means that for every two watts at the meter, only one watt gets to the IT hardware.

Brill writes that PUE claims of 0.9 are “scientifically meaningless, because the marketer making this claim would need to have invented a perpetual motion machine with more energy coming out than coming in.”

Here are some tips Brill recommends:

1. Ask for PUE numbers to be tied to a utility bill and verified by an independent third party to prevent the numbers from being altered.

2. Be aware that electricity is only one of a number of data center energy sources, so some PUE numbers may appear better than they really are.

3. Power is measured at an instant in time, whereas energy is power over time, so a PUE of 1.2 or 1.6 might be accurate but only true at a very carefully selected instant in time.

4. Benchmarking is useful only if you are comparing yourself with others with similar power and cooling equipment types, percentages of load utilization, tier design levels and ZIP codes.

A recent report, developed in part by Uptime, called for an immediate overhaul of corporate management practices and a doubling of the energy efficiency of large-scale corporate computing facilities by 2012.

ADVERTISERS

Join the Discussion

Today's News

Boosting the Triple Bottom Line Using Water Management Strategies

Boosting the Triple Bottom Line Using Water Management Strategies

As American consumers and businesses look for new ways to reduce the environmental impact of daily life, the notion of green buildings ... continue »

False Economies
‘Shovel Ready’ Stimulus – Projects That Should Be Supported
Going Green Starts with Design
How Business Influences Climate Change Policy
Retailers Find Environmental Concerns Playing Larger Role In Reputation

Retailers Find Environmental Concerns Playing Larger Role In Reputation

Retailers have entered a new age of corporate citizenship in which not only working conditions but environmental impacts of production and products ...

click to view full size chart »

LOHAS Consumers Drive Charitable Donations
UN: CDM Increasing Emission-Saving Initiatives, Critics Disagree
CSR Reporting Efforts: Electronics, Financial, and Metals
Fair Isaac CIO Discusses Sustainability Efforts

Fair Isaac CIO Discusses Sustainability Efforts

Here's a in-house video from Fair Isaac - an interview with Christopher Rence, Fair Isaac vice president and chief information officer. Fair ...

click to view video »

Air New Zealand Completes Flight Powered By Jatropha Biofuel
Autodesk Green Design Software
Is Sustainability A Fad Or Here To Stay?
The Bottom Line

Marketing

Greenwash Brigade Looks Back At 2008

Green Business 2008 - Environmental Leader’s Most Popular Stories

StubHub To Plant a Tree For Every Ticket Bought For NFL Post-Season

Emissions

Northeast States Agree to Low Carbon Fuel Standard

Ener1 Applies For DOE Funding

Chicago FBI Building Earns LEED Platinum Certification

Hi-Tech

Fair Isaac CIO Discusses Sustainability Efforts

Connecticut DEP To Finalize Details of Statewide ‘E-waste’ Program

Speedy ROI with Quick Green IT Fixes

Efficiency

Boosting the Triple Bottom Line Using Water Management Strategies

PepsiCo Reports Improved Recycling, Careful Water Use

Restaurants To Become ‘Greener,’ Offer More Local Produce In 2009

Manufacturing

WSJ Slams Dell Over Carbon Neutral Claim

Product Stewardship Policy Gains Support

Rio Tinto Likely To Receive Free Carbon Permits Worth $462M in 2010

Carbon Offsets/RECs

The New Rules of Green Travel

Japan Airlines Jumps on Carbon Offset Bandwagon

SFO Kiosks To Sell Carbon Offsets

CSR Reports

Bombardier Meets 5-Yr Reduction Targets

CSR Reporting Efforts: Electronics, Financial, and Metals

Sustainable Silicon Valley Members Cut CO2 Emissions 27%

Major Players

Lenovo Meets, Exceeds EPA Energy Star Criteria Ahead of Deadline

McDonald’s To Rollout Energy Efficient Systems

Wind Not Quite Enough to Fill Staples’ Sails

See All Topics »