Is it Time for the U.S. to Invest in Solar Manufacturing?

May 18, 2009

Phil Schneider, Principal, Deloitte Consulting LLP
Mike Reno, Partner, Deloitte Tax LLP
Rebecca Ranich, Director, Deloitte Consulting LLP

Email this story Print this post Add your comments

The solar industry is on the brink of dramatic growth. Global manufacturers have come to expect incentives to invest and create jobs, and they’re getting them. Just look at what’s happening in Malaysia and Singapore. Countries all around the world understand the economic and environmental benefits of solar manufacturing investments. Clean, green high-technology jobs in a hurry.

The big question for the solar industry is where manufacturing investment and job growth will happen. Will the U.S. come up with more competitive incentives, or will policymakers take a wait-and-see approach and let the market do its thing? Manufacturers are smart to be cautious.

Many U.S. policymakers recognize the potential benefits of solar manufacturing and are trying to encourage the industry. Yet executives in the world’s largest solar companies say additional incentives, including greater availability of federal tax credits, will be needed to encourage more manufacturing operations, especially foreign companies, to build their plants in the U.S. I think there’s a good chance that will happen – and that global manufacturing leaders should be planning accordingly.

The American Reinvestment and Recovery Act (ARRA) was a good first step. Its alternative energy incentives were popular, but many manufacturers feel the legislation didn’t go far enough to stimulate the supply side of the industry – that is, manufacturing. They are now looking for an expansion of the tax credit caps and loan guarantees, and also believe that more could be done for technical training and Research & Development. To make that happen, manufacturers should be working with policymakers to build on and extend the foundation established with ARRA.

Manufacturers should also consider scenario planning to guide their investment strategies. Incentives for solar manufacturing around the world are literally changing every day. Scenario planning is a smart way to track the potential benefits and risks of market entry strategy.

There’s an opportunity now for global solar companies to get a foothold in U.S.-based manufacturing. Early movers could gain significant benefits – but not without risk. U.S. public policy will likely change dramatically through 2009 and in to 2010. Bottom line? If companies want to influence solar manufacturing policy, including incentives, now is the time to act.

A view from the tax perspective

If policy makers decide they want the U.S. to be a major player in solar manufacturing, they’ll find plenty of effective tools available to turn that vision into reality.

The key lies in understanding exactly what kinds of investments the U.S. wants to attract. For large solar manufacturers, tax incentives will likely be a critical part of the equation. Other factors such as supply chain considerations could also be important.

At the federal level, the use of accelerated depreciation with production and investment tax credits have shown to be reliable mechanisms for spurring investments in alternative energy. They can be targeted and configured to effectively reduce federal income tax liabilities to zero over a specified period of time. More creative options, such as tax holidays, job creation grants, and property tax relief, are more likely to come from various states, which have a long history of putting together incentive packages to attract certain industries – or even specific companies. Where there’s a will, there’s a way.

A view from the sustainability perspective

The debate over solar manufacturing incentives is occurring against a backdrop of potential changes in global policy surrounding energy in general and carbon in particular. Discussions set for Copenhagen later this year will focus on framing global initiatives on climate.

For policy makers and solar manufacturers alike, now is the time to perform cost/benefit analyses on the long-term impact of various manufacturing locations. Solar companies would be smart to give special attention to shipping and transportation cost scenarios, which could shift dramatically if carbon legislation moves forward.

The bottom line is this: the U.S. is likely to become the largest solar market in the world, with potentially enormous growth over the next 20 years. Legislative initiatives currently taking shape in state and federal government are encouraging signs that policy makers understand the strategic value of renewable generation for U.S. energy independence.

But attracting solar manufacturers will likely take broad-based and aggressive action. State incentives will undoubtedly be part of any winning packages, which in combination with renewed federal interest in energy infrastructure, may prove advantageous to solar manufacturers.

Phil Schneider is a Principal at Deloitte Consulting LLP. Mike Reno is a Partner at Deloitte Tax LLP. Rebecca Ranich is a Director at Deloitte Consulting LLP. This article originally appeared at Deloitte.com.

Email this story Print this post Add your comments

Advertisers

Enhance Sustainability. Improve Profitability.

Learn how at the SAP Sustainability Resource Center. >>

EFFECTIVELY MANAGE WATER COMPLIANCE

Understand how increased enforcement may affect your company. Find out more >>

EPA mandatory emissions reporting starts Jan 1st

CSA Standards can help your organization get ready for compliance. Find out how. >>

Join the Discussion

Reader Comments

The growth of the solar market in the U.S. is great news for job seekers, with as many as 110,000 jobs expected to be created in the next two years alone.

Frank | May 19th, 2009