Greenpeace: Electronics Cut Chemicals, Recycling Still Poor
Rankings by the non-profit found that more electronics products than ever are free of potentially hazardous chemicals, and most products evaluated meet or exceed Energy Star efficiency standards.
But Greenpeace said companies’ “lifecycle management”, including use of recycled plastics, is still wanting. Take-back practices have shown some improvement, Greenpeace said.
The organization’s third Green Electronics Survey ranked desktop computers, laptops, netbooks, monitors, mobile phones, smartphones and televisions.
Laptops performed particularly poorly, with the best scoring product in that category achieving only 67% of possible points. The best-scoring monitor, in contrast, scored 87%.
“This means that the best scoring notebook includes fewer of all the available green features for notebooks, while the best scoring monitor has less to learn from its competitors,” the report noted.
Greenpeace said electronic companies are clearly phasing out the use of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and brominated flame retardants (BFRs) – substances for which Greenpeace served penalty points in previous editions of the rankings. All mobile phones ranked were PVC-free.
None of the laptops ranked were completely PVC or BFR-free, but Greenpeace noted that Apple’s new MacBook Pro is free of those chemicals. Apple chose not to participate in the survey.
“As Apple’s MacBook managed to eliminate these last uses of PVC and become the first 100% PVC-free notebook computer, there is no longer a technical hurdle for the rest of the industry to overcome,” Greenpeace said.
The vast majority of products in the survey meet Energy Star standards for energy efficiency. But some products still lagged far behind, with the worst-performing smartphone only achieving 13% of possible energy efficiency points.
Greenpeace said the use of post-consumer recycled plastic is still not standard practice for laptops, netbooks and smartphones, though monitors, desktops and mobile phones are doing better in this area. Sony Ericsson won full marks on this measure for its Elm phone, which uses 60% post-industrial recycled plastic.
But Greenpeace said it was concerned that the minimum electronic warranties never go beyond three years, with most laptops, netbooks and TVs offering only one-year contracts.
Last month Ericsson finished in second place for its climate change efforts in Greenpeace’s Cool IT rankings.
Another Greenpeace report last month said that electronics retailer Best Buy was among several major companies “failing our forests”.
Energy Manager News
- Saving Energy – In the Restroom
- UAB Getting First Solar Array
- California is Among the National Leaders in Energy Efficiency and Economic Gains
- Westerly, RI, Making Moves to Improve Municipal Efficiency
- SCE&G Customers to See Lower Bills, Renewable Energy Charge Starting in May
- Marin Clean Energy Could Cut Rates As Seven More Cities Join
- ASHRAE Looks at Energy Efficiency in a World Without Price Tags
- New York City Goes Big on Solar